Practical Science on Movement and Pain

The Rubber Hand Illusion

Many 18th c. treatments for psychological dist...

Image via Wikipedia

Neuroscience is to some extent an exercise in reverse engineering the brain. Reverse engineering means trying to understand how a complex device works without knowledge of its design or access to the owner’s manual. One of the basic tools of reverse engineering is to disable one part of the machine and then see what effect that has on the machine’s function.

In trying to understand how the brain works, scientists can’t just disable parts of people’s brains and then see what happens. But they can do some harmless tricks to cause the brain to malfunction a little. This is why neuroscientists like studying illusions. An illusion is basically a failure of the brain to perform one of its most basic tasks – creating a subjective experience which corresponds to reality. So by understanding how and why the brain can fail in this function, you can better understand how the function is performed.

The rubber hand illusion reveals some interesting facts about the way the brain creates the self image. It also might make a fairly entertaining party trick, provided that you have decided to bring a rubber hand to a party. Here’s how it works.

The Illusion

The victim of the illusion places both hands down on a table. The left hand is placed on the outside of a screen to block it from view, and a rubber hand is placed on the inside of the screen in a place that makes it look roughly like the left hand. So the subject looks down at the table and sees his right hand and a rubber hand where the left would normally be. The real left hand is out of sight.

Then the illusionist strokes the rubber hand and the hidden hand at the same time on the same finger. So the subject now sees the rubber hand being stroked on the ring finger while at the same time feeling her left hand being stroked on the ring finger. After a few strokes the subject gets the uncanny feeling that the rubber hand belongs to her. In fact, the subject will flinch when the rubber hand is threatened. So, the brain makes a big mistake by basically taking ownership of something it does not own. What does this tell us about how the brain creates the self image?

Altered Maps

First, let’s review what is meant by self-image. The self image is the brain’s representation of the position, activity, and condition of all the various body parts. The representation is created by networks of neurons in specific areas of the brain called body maps. So, there is a specific part of the brain devoted to mapping the hand, another devoted to mapping the elbow, etc.

The rubber hand illusion illustrates several interesting facts about how the maps work. First, the maps can be changed radically in just moments. It has been known for some time that the brain will map inanimate objects that are often close to the body such as a tennis racquet, cane, or a cowboy hat. With the rubber hand, the brain not only maps it, but maps it in such a way that the hand is considered part of the body. It is noteworthy that this happens even though the conscious mind is completely aware that the rubber hand is not part of the body.

Another thing we can learn from the rubber hand illusion is that the brain creates maps by integrating sensory information from multiple sources, not just sensory information from the relevant body part. In other words, in deciding what is going on with the left hand, the brain doesn’t just listen to the signals from the left hand – it also listens to the signals from the eyes. In this case, the brain obviously placed a higher value on the visual information, because the left hand was effectively saying – “I’m over here behind the screen”, while the eyes were saying, “no, the hand is right here in front of you, it just looks a little rubbery.” The brain was swayed by the testimony from the eyes, proving the truth of the expressions “seeing is believing” and “out of sight out of mind.”

There is another fascinating aspect to this experiment. The hidden hand actually becomes colder after the body takes ownership of the rubber hand. This shows that the brain’s representations of the body parts can have significant and immediate effects on physiologic processes related to those body parts. As stated by a team of researchers led by Lorimer Moseley and Charles Spence: “these findings show that the conscious sense of our physical self, and the physiological regulation of our physical self, are linked. In fact our results suggest that the conscious sense of our physical self may actually contribute to its homeostatic regulation.”

I think this is an incredibly significant finding. I have stated at numerous times on this blog that the health and accuracy of the maps or virtual bodies in the brain is just as important as the health of the actual physical tissues in the body for determining how we move and feel. However, I didn’t realize until now that the accuracy of the virtual bodies could actually directly affect the health of the real ones.

This opens up all sort of speculations about the interconnectedness between the maps and the body. Perhaps a part of the body that is underrepresented in the brain will not receive adequate blood supply or immune support. Perhaps a part of the body that is overrepresented receives too much immune support and is prone to inflammation. It is worth noting that body temperature malfunctions have been reported in people with peripheral nerve damage, schizophrenia, and self harm tendencies. Perhaps inaccurate maps play a role here.

In any event, even a conservative look at the meaning of the rubber hand illusion would lead one to conclude, as stated by cognitive neuroscience researcher Stephen Mitch Roth, that “it does seem like there are these connections, broadly speaking, between awareness and physiological changes.”

Indeed. Yet again more evidence that Moshe Feldenkrais was way ahead of his time in believing that awareness and self-image play a large role in our physical and mental well-being.

Enhanced by Zemanta
Enjoy the post?
Sign up for blog post updates and get an e-report on improving mobility.

10 Responses to The Rubber Hand Illusion

  1. Matt P says:

    The more I read things, like this, coming out of neuroscience, the more I’m becoming convinced that not only our health, but our beliefs about What Works in exercise and fitness training is a function of our beliefs.

    I don’t think we can even look at the subject as a purely biological phenomenon anymore. Neuro-psychological elements simply have too much influence on the system.

  2. Thanks for the comment Matt.

    I agree that the rubber hand illusion has implications for exercise. I wouldn’t be surprised if, all things equal, lifting weight in a way that is neurologically interesting would cause a greater stimulus for growth than lifting the same weights in a way that the CNS considers boring.

  3. Stefan says:

    Really interesting.

    I remember a ted talk where V.S. Ramachandran talked about curing the phantom pain of amputees using the exact same trick.

  4. Alfredo says:

    Brilliant. Very interesting post.

  5. [...] In the second study, scientists were able to cut the pain of hand osteoarthritis in half by subjecting the painful hands to some interesting illusions. These were created with some software that uses computer manipulated video images, combined with actual pulling or pushing on the hand, to fool the brain into believing the hand is stretching or shrinking. (For some idea on how this might work see here.) [...]

  6. [...] traumatic in the moment. Modern psychotherapy is more refined, but as is seen in this article on the Rubber Hand, our minds are easily fooled into believing a new ‘story’ if it seems plausible. We are [...]

  7. [...] looks into the interactions of pain and movement. He explains the experiment below. Please read the whole article here. I just pulled out a few paragraphs that highlighted the point that I found particularly [...]

  8. Luis Vazquez says:

    Is it true to say that the brain and body react to the conscious when the subject of the experiment consciously knows the truth? Is the illusion a conscious perception? Please help me to understand.

    • Todd Hargrove says:

      Luis,

      The illusion exists for people even though they consciously know it’s an illusion. Try it, it’s not that tough to do the experiment with the help of a friend (and a rubber hand).

Leave a reply