Practical Science on Movement and Pain

High Heels, Barefeet, and Running in Circles

English: Red High Heel Pumps

Image via Wikipedia

Three new studies recently emerged that shed light on how gait changes our structure and function. I thought it would be interesting to discuss them all at the same time.

High heels are bad

It is known that wearing high heels tends to shorten the calf muscles and stiffen the achilles tendon. Shocker. Some researchers were curious what effects this might have on gait mechanics. So they recruited a group of women who wore high heels (more than 5cm) for at least 40 hours a week for two years. The control group rarely wore heels.

The women walked barefoot while the scientists collected data. Analysis revealed that the high heel group on average took shorter strides and did more work with the calf muscles to propel themselves forward. The low heelers used longer strides, stretched their achilles tendons further, and thereby gained more forward energy “for free” in the form of the release of the stored energy of the elastic tendons. Score one for low heels.

Minimal footwear is good?

In another recent study, Daniel Lieberman’s group recruited some people who habitually run with minimal footwear to run in their minimal footwear and then in normal running shoes. Guess what? Their gait was more efficient in the minimal footwear. This should be no major surprise. I would expect anyone to run most efficiently in the shoes they are accustomed to using. The study would have been more interesting if it included runners who wear mainstream running shoes. Would they have more or less efficient gaits than the minimal runners? Would they improve if they put on the Vibrams? We don’t know. But the study does show that footwear affects gait efficiency.

Running in circles

In the third study, researchers recruited a bunch of runners who spend a lot of time running around a track in the same direction. They found that the muscle reflexes were different from side to side. This was not found in the control group, so this was interpreted as an adaptation to the monotonous same direction running.

Conclusion

So what is the take away here? For me, it is that the structure and function of the body are always adapting to imposed stress in highly specific ways. Some of the adaptations will probably be harmless, and others will probably lead to problems (e.g. the high heels). But one way or the other, how you move will leave its mark.

Enjoy the post?
Sign up for blog post updates and get an e-report on improving mobility.

3 Responses to High Heels, Barefeet, and Running in Circles

  1. I see Lieberman’s study as effective. I have both minimal footwear, vibram five finger and normal running shoes. As weird as it may sound, the 1/4″ sole of the minimal shoes screws up my normal gait that I have with my vibrams. Around 2.5 miles, my back will flare up and need an adjustment from a Chiropractor when I wear my minimal shoes. I prefer running in the five fingers. I run farther and experience less physical fatigue and pain. I haven’t run in normal running shoes for over two years. I think Lieberman has clearly documented in other studies the efficiency of running barefoot over traditional running shoes.

  2. Todd Hargrove says:

    Ross,

    I agree that the Lieberman study is useful, I just wish it had more controls. Interesting about your back being sensitive to the shoes. I have heard similar things from others.

    I think you may be right about the other studies by Lieberman I should look those up.

  3. […] Why You Shouldn’t Wear High Heels 10 Attempts Phys Ed: Brains and Brawn Excellence The Truth About Sleep & Productivity Why Goals (and Family) Matter Celebrity trainer, Bob Harper, talks CrossFit […]

Leave a reply